Is This Evidence For Reincarnation?

Let us have an open mind!
 
Let us seriously study -- with a very open mind -- the circumstances and known facts about the curious news reports about the UP village boy who suddenly acquired "American accent".
 
Just to help us recall, I give the following links to the initial reports:-
 
 
b) Debate on the subject at CNN IBN - http://in.news.yahoo.com/070714/211/6i1bl.html
 
 
What are the incontrovertible facts regarding the case?
 
a) Rajesh, is a teenager from a remote village in India
 
b) He is today able to talk English with American accent and gestures, which is amazing, considering the unlikely conditions at his home and village.
 
 
Claims in the initial news reports that needed to be independently validated:-
 
a) He has forgotten to speak Hindi
 
b) He has acquired more than ordinary knowledge of physics and mathematics (which allegedly left "engineering students baffled")
 
c) He has written three "documents" -- on memory, on sociology and on liberalization
 
 
Findings by Zee News (who investigated a bit on the above):-
 
a) The boy can still understand and talk in Hindi
 
b) The boy admitted that he developed the accent and mannerisms by constantly watching Hollywood movies on TV -- a few years back, he had taken up learning English as a "challenge" after having been insulted by a teacher.
 
c) His ability to speak English is merely imitative, that he spoke the language with grammatical errors; and that he could not fully comprehend questions asked in English.
 
 Reasonable Conclusions
 
a) The boy's ability to talk English with a US accent is the result of extraordinary skills of imitation and mimicry that he happens to posses. He acquired this ability merely by repeatedly watching Hollywood movies, and through hard practice. This is indeed an amazing ability -- but one that does not call for supernatural explanations!
 
b) There is no evidence at all that the boy was "recalling" events from the memory of his earlier birth as a US scientist.
 
c) This incident does not in any way suggest that reincarnation (or punarjanma) is a possibility -- yet there can be no doubt that for years to come, the purveyors of the "supernatural" will use this news item to suggest that science (which discounts the possibility of rebirth after death) does not have an "open mind" on the issue!



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

  Genes And Memes All about  Genes  [This is the first of a two part blog series which covers the  genes . I will take up  memes  in the next part]   How come Giraffes came to have such long necks? It would seem that the ancient ancestors of the Giraffe were more like other herbivores. They did not have necks that were particularly long, as these are in modern day Giraffes. How did the long necks evolve in nature? Many people believe that  early animals with normal necks had to repeatedly stretch these out to eat leaves that were higher up from the ground, and that this “effort” slowly made their necks grow longer. And that the offspring of these animals were then born with longer necks. This explanation is totally wrong! This is not the way biological evolution proceeds in nature. The observed fact is that traits that are acquired within the life time of an animal (through effort or accident) cannot be inherited by the next generation. What gets ...
Read more
  Death Penalty -- Is This A SMART Strategy? The recent [14 years ago!] award of death penalty to a person convicted for involvement in a terror attack has regenerated the old debate on capital punishment. Those who favour death penalty have the following rational reasons:- a) This is a deterrent against similar crimes by others in future b) The convicted person, if not "eliminated", may one day get free, and may re-enact the crime The above hard nosed reasons are often furbished with  more emotional ones such as of  "justice to the victims", anger, revenge, patriotic fervour etc. Let us analyse the above from our own experience -- and that of others. How smart is capital punishment as a strategy to prevent future crime and terror? Years back -- when Indira Gandhi was the Prime Minister and when terrorism was hardly an issue in Kashmir -- India had hanged another killer, Maqbul Butt of the JKLF. The fact that we eliminated (through due process of law) a prospective ...
Read more
Memes And Morality The concept of meme can be fully appreciated only if the term "gene" is well understood. It is strongly recommended that the blog  Genes and Memes  is read before proceeding further. What makes human beings distinct from the rest of the living creatures is perhaps the tool  of "language" that we came to possess, somewhere along the tortuous path of biological evolution.   Language enables us to share ideas with each other in a more sophisticated and nuanced manner than was ever possible without this tool. It is the tool of language that has led to the "memetic revolution". For those who are new to "memes", a meme is simply an idea that copies itself from one brain to another brain through language or imitation -- and which often gets mutated (altered) during the process of repeated copying. Memes are like genes -- but memes transmit ONLY horizontally among people  after  they are  born, whereas genes transmit ONLY vertically fr...
Read more